BLUE
SP
Simon Pratt
@simonpratt.bsky.social
Senior Lecturer, University of Melbourne SSPS. Formerly of other places. Research: war, intelligence, and normative change in international politics. Cat paparazzo, BJJ-er, bad violinist. He/Him 🇨🇦🏳️‍🌈✡️
407 followers85 following469 posts
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Oh. I misunderstood. There's a very long list of bombings during war that kill 10 or so combatants, and seriously injure a few hundred more combatants, while generally avoiding noncombatant casualties. So long that it would be impossible to exhaustively compile. Do you want one example at random?

1
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Police action is essentially violent because any attempt to resist the police generates a violent response. The violence doesn't go away just because most people cooperate. The violence is in the service of the state so it is essentially political. Anyway, this is a bit of a digression.

1
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Use of traps attached to certain kinds of people or in certain kinds of places is a war crime. Since the pagers are moving around, picked up by kids or placed next to them, taken into various protected places, this could never really have been IHL compliant. ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/customary...

1
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Yeah. Some of this can be achieved simply by the discovery of the bombs rather than by their detonation, which can be treated as as lesser benefit weighed against the greater diplomatic costs of committing an action likely to sit poorly with international partners in a new arena of conflict.

0
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Doesn't work

0
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

According to this definition virtually all police action and certainly all judicial action resulting in confinement is terrorism. While I certainly have some radical colleagues who would support this conclusion, I don't think it suggests a helpful set of analytical boundaries.

1
Reposted by Simon Pratt
KAatherton.bsky.social

The existence of precision weapons is often framed as a tool allowing for reduction of civilian casualties but that's a sort of backwards logic and convenient misrepresentation, fostered in no small part by a decade of drone war emphasizing "targeted strikes."

8
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

Israel is already at war with Hizbullah.

1
SPsimonpratt.bsky.social

My thought is maybe they triggered by accident, since there's no attempt to exploit the blow to H's comms and command&control. There's minimal strategic benefit here on its own.

0
SP
Simon Pratt
@simonpratt.bsky.social
Senior Lecturer, University of Melbourne SSPS. Formerly of other places. Research: war, intelligence, and normative change in international politics. Cat paparazzo, BJJ-er, bad violinist. He/Him 🇨🇦🏳️‍🌈✡️
407 followers85 following469 posts