I've just posted on @ssrn.bsky.socialpapers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers....
I canāt believe Iāve been put in this position but this is a really incorrect framing of the concurrence. Whatās worse, the misreading is getting folks to reflexively dismiss an opinion that wants to limit judgesā equitable power ā¦ which is ostensibly a lefty goal.
one thing to remember is that the central holding in plessy v. ferguson was not āsegregation goodā but that the constitution neither recognized social inequality as a fact in the world nor gave courts the power to remedy it. the constitution, under plessy, could neither see nor touch racism.
Thomas suggests the court overreached its authority in the landmark decision.
I think my dude hedged way too much.
Appreciation post: this is one of my fav legislation pieces in recent memory.
Another Way to Rebut Major Questions Arguments, by Todd Phillips and Beau J. Baumann
I kind of think the preservation of the American system of government has depended on periodically forgetting the "Anti-Power Concentration Principle."