Its ok! The joke is theres like 50+ characters that fit this description so DO NOT FEEL BAD DIFIFJDIDI EVEN THE HUNTERS ,,, ARGUABLY DONT KNO Going from top to bottom row, its Bluestar, Crowfeather, Ashfur (a tricky one too bc... this is. Actually. A spoiler depiction (; ) and Cinderpelt uncolored!

OHH CINER! I got everyone else right so good on me for remembering silly cat book characters (I haven't picked on up in like two years😭), but mostly good on you for absolutely AMAZING characterization! Ashfurs face expression *eats*