Just to make this clear - I *loved* RDR2

RDR is so frustrating, because those games clearly show that Rockstar can make incredible games, but they insist on making GTA instead

even RDR1 dipped into that dumb, edgy satire tone with a lot of the characters (especially in the Mexico parts), but 2 managed to strike a really serious, beautiful tone. the Rockstar Humor seems mostly contained to the performances which you can go nearly the whole game without seeing