Nah, I can't see that being unpopular. That's just a matter of wanting to keep the feel of the game consistent. If everyone is playing serious characters, and you show up with Bulk Grogan, then that'll change things a bit.

This happens without fail once per campaign. Someone always comes to the table with some pun-ass goofy-ass thing with this smug grin so damn chuffed with themselves for making a recolored indiana jones or star wars alien or meme reference like Im going to laugh It just shows me you don't care tbh