BLUE
WG
William Gunn
@drgunn.bsky.social
Communications and community. More here: synthesis.williamgunn.org/about/
115 followers57 following154 posts
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

Yeah, it's not a great comparison, just more a way to think about the ethics of what the re-sharing group did. They added little in a quantitative sense and the addition didn't really qualitatively change things either, right?

0
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

Not an authoritative opinion in any way, but I wonder if the Fair Use Doctrine provides a useful framework for thinking about this. The framework proposed several tests, including the amount used and whether it was a "transformative use". Perhaps this is a matter of degree?

1
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

I have seen some real howlers! Threads on pipe that doesn't match any known thread size, missing essential safety measures... It's almost like the CPSC is a good thing

0
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

Step 1: Find a picture of a piece of equipment that sells well. Step 2: Using the cheapest, heaviest/flimsiest materials possible, make a thing that looks like the picture. Step 3: Take a picture of the thing you made from its best side and not too close-up. Step 4: R&D and design is done.

1
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

Newsblur! newsblur.com/ Maybe about 10% of company CMSs I see don't produce feeds.

1
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

It's unclear why @OpenAI didn't consult with any actual biologists for the development of the assessment process.

0
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

3. The scoring rubric doesn't work, even if they had something to score against. Is a cheap and undetectable bio but less deadly agent more successful than an expensive and difficult and to deploy but more deadly agent?

1
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

Imagine the change in @OpenAI's security posture required for them to safely have working instructions for making all manner of CBRN threats. 2. The information gathering ability of researchers varies highly, making their baseline extremely variable and confounding comparisons.

1
WGdrgunn.bsky.social

If the success rate of the group with access to the model is more accurate, complete, and innovative, then the improvement is deemed due to the model. There are numerous problems with this. 1. It presumes access to a classified gold standard successful prep doc for all threats!

1
WG
William Gunn
@drgunn.bsky.social
Communications and community. More here: synthesis.williamgunn.org/about/
115 followers57 following154 posts