For the record, the Acolyte should only have ever been a one-season show anyway. It didn't need a season 2; we don't need to see every character as they move into their future. It's okay to just be shown an origin story that sets up a character or two, and tells us that they're out there somewhere

The man-babies only wanted a season 2 because they want a moody bad guy in whom they think they feel they can see a bit of themselvess, and because they wanted to nerd out over Darth Plagueis. They would have inevitably hated whatever the show did with Plagueis anyway