I'll put FFXIV pre-shadowbringers at #6. I don't really like this game anymore, but it was peak MMO back in the heavensward and stormblood eras and I had so much fun. Shame they made the game so boring in recent expansions, but at least you can be a hrothgar now I guess!

Parasite Eve is pretty high up, I'll put that at #7. A game I replay every christmas, it's such a great and unique experience being half horror and half rpg, traumatized me a bit as a kid too. I would love a remake someday. Strange they only made one of them.