Agree. There is another study recently published (but the authprs cannot conclude very much) that prereg could improve replicability. But it is just a suggestion among many: journals.plos.org/plosone/arti... . And I completely agree with you.
Introduction Previous studies about the replicability of clinical research based on the published literature have suggested that highly cited articles are often contradicted or found to have inflated ...
Why do you say that? Just curious. Theres a lot of things I dont know in the philosophy of science domain.
What do you think about Hensson? Regarding demarcation.
For RCTs (journals.plos.org/plosone/arti...) and psychology makes a lot of sense that prereg, no outcome switching, sample size, etc. would improve replicability. But in many other fields such as very basic science degrees of freedom can be exponential and quality control may be very important.
Introduction Previous studies about the replicability of clinical research based on the published literature have suggested that highly cited articles are often contradicted or found to have inflated ...
Messed*
Maybe it is not a problem of OSF per si but the authors medded things up with time.
P.s.: The authors qere very conservative in any giving conclusion.
There is another paper suggesting that prereg could improve replicability: journals.plos.org/plosone/arti... . Please could you take a look and see if the code and data are more FAIR?
Introduction Previous studies about the replicability of clinical research based on the published literature have suggested that highly cited articles are often contradicted or found to have inflated ...
Foe the ones following the sebate around the retraction of the paper from paychology: There is another paper suggesting that prereg could improve replicability but we cannot conclude anything: journals.plos.org/plosone/arti.... Reproducibility challenges are going to vary across disciplines.
Introduction Previous studies about the replicability of clinical research based on the published literature have suggested that highly cited articles are often contradicted or found to have inflated ...
There is another paper suggesting that prereg could improve replicability but we cannot conclude anything: journals.plos.org/plosone/arti.... But I think reproducibility challenges are going to vary across different fields.
Introduction Previous studies about the replicability of clinical research based on the published literature have suggested that highly cited articles are often contradicted or found to have inflated ...