BLUE
Profile banner
MH
Matthew Hurteau
@mhurteau.bsky.social
Forest ecologist studying forest-fire-climate interactions. www.hurteaulab.org
415 followers210 following62 posts
MHmhurteau.bsky.social

It is perfectly acceptable. Just did this. Have published and been rejected by journals where I was serving as AE. Have handled these types of submissions too. It did not influence my decision.

1

SVthetreecorener.bsky.social

Understood. I was trying to relay that it was the head editor of the journal whose grad student submitted the paper and because the AE may be in the same field as the head editor it may become a COI. Should they show deference to their colleague or my critical review from outside the field?

1
Profile banner
MH
Matthew Hurteau
@mhurteau.bsky.social
Forest ecologist studying forest-fire-climate interactions. www.hurteaulab.org
415 followers210 following62 posts