I think I read an earlier version of this along with the "faculty" web posting. My suggestion is, if you are able, take it upon yourself/yourselves to post the entire corpus of data that Taibbi obtained. Then whenever you see a quote out of context, you can follow up with a different perspective.

Meanwhile it's not all that difficult to point out Taibbi's adventures as an expat in Russia and the entertaining but grossly misogynistic prose he generated there. Nor the defects of other quasi-journalism he has created since then.