BLUE
Profile banner
SC
Seth Cotlar
@sethcotlar.bsky.social
Teaches US History at Willamette Univ. Working on a book about the long history of the US Right. sethcotlar.substack.com/
16.7k followers2.3k following10.2k posts
SCsethcotlar.bsky.social

He and Nate Silver strike me as perfect examples of how a white guy can get one important thing right one time, and from that time forward be treated like a genius about everything rather than just your average, mediocre analyst who made one good call.

26

Rsteenyswank.bsky.social

Thank you for succinctly explaining 30 years of frustration with this mf.

0
Nthewesterhazys.bsky.social

No one in power ever seems to notice the calls this sector of media people miss so it behooves them to keep making them regardless of knowledge or experience with a given matter.

0
AVadamvann.bsky.social

I assume the one important thing for Nate was predicting the rise of the 2008 Tampa Bay Rays, which many of us used to make a small fortune. Been all downhill since that

0
AMmerz.bsky.social

"Too many preachy females…"

0
GBjm6k.bsky.social

and they both just lucked in to those single correct calls, it turns out.

0
SCsethcotlar.bsky.social

Jim Carville hasn't had "his finger on the pulse of working class, rural America" since the early 90s when he first became a famous and wealthy political strategist...just because he sounds like what coastal liberals think a "working class white guy" sounds like, it doesn't actually make him one.

5
SSboleteful.bsky.social

I mean preachiness is real but it's clearly not even remotely limited to democrat women in the party.

2
KJgoondocks.online

This means we're going to get at least another 30 years of bad Silver takes.

0
KKitshard.bsky.social

Years ago there was lots of ink spilled re: “how can a Republican and Democratic strategist be married? Amazing!” But if you hear him talk for 5 minutes, you realize he’s pretty far right and a terrible human.

0
Mmaxjes.bsky.social

Carville doesn’t exist in isolation. He’s emblematic of parts of the party that have ossified into a living time capsule. It is always 1992, the correct move is always to court moderate republicans, base and youth told to swallow the tough pill. Mr. 538 on the other hand is just internet poisoned.

0
Profile banner
SC
Seth Cotlar
@sethcotlar.bsky.social
Teaches US History at Willamette Univ. Working on a book about the long history of the US Right. sethcotlar.substack.com/
16.7k followers2.3k following10.2k posts