Too late! Caslon was later C18th. Although the design is similar to C17th fonts it’s not quite the same. (Plus Adobe Caslon doesn’t have enough different weights anyway!)

I don't like most of Adobe's revivals at all, but there are SO MANY good ones by other foundries in many genres. This list might not help, but could be pleasant to review: typography.symbo1ics.com#book-serifs Disclaimer: super subjective, may be inaccurate, and aren't sorted into recommendations