Found Joseph Henshaw's probate inventory in Middletown, CT, 1787 on Ancestry.comlibrary.usi.edu/record/679090

Brothers "washed from the deck of their ship during a strong gale in the West Indies." www.rawbw.com/~hinshaw/cgi...

Here's some more: www.rawbw.com/~hinshaw/cgi... Seems they were brothers "washed from the deck of their ship during a strong gale in the West Indies."

Thanks, Shirley! I was close but was trying James instead of Joseph. This is super helpful.