BLUE
Profile banner
TG
Trish Greenhalgh
@trishgreenhalgh.bsky.social
Professor of Primary Care Health Sciences, Oxford University. Researching digital health (esp inequities), covid prevention (masks/ air quality). Member of Independent SAGE. Wild swimmer. Mum to Rob (marine bio) and Al (doc). Not medical advice. #medsky
12.6k followers1.7k following1k posts

BMJ commission me to write editorial on patient involvement. Submitting it, I'm asked for key words. I suggest 'patient involvement', 'patient', 'PPI', 'lay involvement' and many more. Each time, response is "you are not allowed to invent your own key words". @bmj.com can you fix this please?

13

BKbinitakane.bsky.social

🤦🏽‍♀️

0
HBhbuckingham.bsky.social

Try 'co-production' and watch the meltdown!

1
TBbmj.com

Hi Trish, thanks for your message. Sorry to hear this has been frustrating. I checked with a member of our team who says in our scholar one submission system, authors select keywords for their paper from a preset list of MeSH terms (Medical Subject Headings www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/) . . .

1
Mmycams.bsky.social

That seems to imply that BMJ is not wanting to involve patients in 'their' jobs! Speaking as a lay person the optics (grinds teeth) are stunningly bad for BMJ.

1
MRmichaeljrigby.bsky.social

Totally regressive and set against progress. Not just for this paper (which they asked for), but any new concept or discovery.

0
alisonkmcc.bsky.social

I’d also comment on this in the editorial. An example of the inverse discoverabilty law in action- restricting findability of pieces by minimising choice of key words. The opposite of what we teach students exploring the literature for the first time. Even patient involvement is in MESH.

0

I was commissioned for something too—winter edition?

0

Sigh.

0
Handrewj27.bsky.social

Invent!! 😳

0

Yes and: “Patient” isn’t already a keyword in the bloody BMJ??? Wow.

0
Profile banner
TG
Trish Greenhalgh
@trishgreenhalgh.bsky.social
Professor of Primary Care Health Sciences, Oxford University. Researching digital health (esp inequities), covid prevention (masks/ air quality). Member of Independent SAGE. Wild swimmer. Mum to Rob (marine bio) and Al (doc). Not medical advice. #medsky
12.6k followers1.7k following1k posts