I'll talk to old heads about it and they say something to the effect: "Phil ruined the band by making it more commercial and pop orientated" well okay but have you even listened to A Trick of the Tail? Wind and Wuthering? or how about And Then There Were Three? even Duke had more prog influence imo

and I love Peter Gabriel! but let's not act like he didn't make the same turn that Phil did. Shock the Monkey isn't prog