BLUE
IS
Impudent Strumpet
@impudentstrumpet.bsky.social
Translator, blogger, wanna-be inventor, random internet stranger She/elle/sie/ella/ona Location: Toronto impstrump.blogspot.com
74 followers60 following1.2k posts

Yes, I've long theorized that Debate (as a school subject/activity) does harm, because it might lead impressionable kids to think that being good at arguing is what *makes* a person's position correct. Also reinforces the idea of arguments being A or B, when IRL it's more often X^Y-Z+2

7

Eflaterik.bsky.social

More people need to understand that being persuasive is orthogonal to being correct

0
AHbbofun.bsky.social

See: Charlie Kirk

0
Wwonkish.bsky.social

It might have been because the form of debating I did involved you being randomly assigned the position you're going to argue, but I found that much more taught people that the skill with which you make your arguments is what matters in a debate, but that doesn't mean it's actually correct.

0

Future lawyers love it because lawyers argue whatever they're paid to argue

0
Cclutchgut.bsky.social

Hello guess who was friends with someone in highschool who was in the debate club and also had very strong and "correct" opinions. You're spot on.

0
JKjeffreykeese.bsky.social

Winning supersedes being actually correct. It’s awful.

0
Llambelly.bsky.social

Arguably this is how Ben Shapiro came in to being.

0
IS
Impudent Strumpet
@impudentstrumpet.bsky.social
Translator, blogger, wanna-be inventor, random internet stranger She/elle/sie/ella/ona Location: Toronto impstrump.blogspot.com
74 followers60 following1.2k posts