BLUE
Profile banner
KH
Kat Holt
@katholt.bsky.social
Scientist… pathogen genomics & antimicrobial resistance, computational biology & infectious disease epi. Co-Director LSHTM AMR Centre. Academic Editor PLoS Biology. holtlab.net | klebnet.org | typhoidgenomics.org | amr.lshtm.ac.uk
402 followers139 following35 posts
KHkatholt.bsky.social

Fundamentally, if the journal is not actually peer reviewing the software, what is the point of them publishing an article describing it? Answer: Advertising (for the authors) and citations (for the journal). None of this lives up to the purpose or standards of scholarly publishing.

1

KHkatholt.bsky.social

Authors - post a description of the software, Nature - write a news feature covering this… dressing it up with the veneer of a peer reviewed article is a damaging farce. Submit for peer review when you’re ACTUALLY READY to be reviewed.

0
Profile banner
KH
Kat Holt
@katholt.bsky.social
Scientist… pathogen genomics & antimicrobial resistance, computational biology & infectious disease epi. Co-Director LSHTM AMR Centre. Academic Editor PLoS Biology. holtlab.net | klebnet.org | typhoidgenomics.org | amr.lshtm.ac.uk
402 followers139 following35 posts