BLUE
Profile banner
ON
Osita Nwanevu
@ositanwanevu.bsky.social
Contributing Editor | The New Republic Columnist | The Guardian Newsletter | ositanwanevu.com
18.5k followers880 following972 posts
ONositanwanevu.bsky.social

Is anyone going to do anything? Ever? What's it going to take? You can't put out a song with an uncleared sample without putting yourself in legal jeopardy; meanwhile these people are openly stealing all of human creation and bragging about it! www.nytimes.com/2024/04/06/t...

How Tech Giants Cut Corners to Harvest Data for A.I.
OpenAI, Google and Meta ignored corporate policies, altered their own rules and discussed skirting copyright law as they sought online information to train their newest artificial intelligence systems.
Ahmad Al-Dahle, Meta’s vice president of generative A.I., told executives that his team had used almost every available English-language book, essay, poem and news article on the internet to develop a model, according to recordings of internal meetings, which were shared by an employee.

Meta could not match ChatGPT unless it got more data, Mr. Al-Dahle told colleagues. In March and April 2023, some of the company’s business development leaders, engineers and lawyers met nearly daily to tackle the problem.
Some debated paying $10 a book for the full licensing rights to new titles. They discussed buying Simon & Schuster, which publishes authors like Stephen King, according to the recordings.

They also talked about how they had summarized books, essays and other works from the internet without permission and discussed sucking up more, even if that meant facing lawsuits. One lawyer warned of “ethical” concerns around taking intellectual property from artists but was met with silence, according to the recordings.

Mr. Zuckerberg demanded a solution, employees said.
Meta’s executives said OpenAI seemed to have used copyrighted material without permission. It would take Meta too long to negotiate licenses with publishers, artists, musicians and the news industry, they said, according to the recordings.

“The only thing that’s holding us back from being as good as ChatGPT is literally just data volume,” Nick Grudin, a vice president of global partnership and content, said in one meeting.

OpenAI appeared to be taking copyrighted material and Meta could follow this “market precedent,” he added.
58

Cconvolver.bsky.social

Man, imagine being in-house counsel for freaking Facebook and still thinking raising ethical concerns is going to get you anywhere with your employer.

0
WBwndlb.bsky.social

At the beginning of hip-hop, it was the same Wild West, until a few federal Judges were VERY unimpressed with the samplers’ arguments.

0
Kthervterrorists.bsky.social

I say let's get Taylor Swift on this. She'll straighten out those bitches.

0

"One lawyer warned of “ethical” concerns around taking intellectual property from artists but was met with silence, according to the recordings." That says everything you need to know about the people involved.

0
Ppolicyg.bsky.social

I wonder if you purchase a university if you would get the rights to all the papers written by the students. Seems like a good way to get a lot of content.

1
TRtrai70.bsky.social

These people don't care about consequences because they've never faced any. I keep thinking about the moment in The Social Network where Zuck had to pay off the Winks, and it was framed as "a speeding ticket."

0
JKjaykellett.bsky.social

Fix copyright law. It is the only way out of this mess.

1
DKzdp189.bsky.social

Couldn't someone make an AI law-bot to identify likely plagiarised works and issue DMCA takedown notices?

0
Pkeeptheskyblue.bsky.social

Governments have let the tech companies become far too big and abusive, and now we are all paying the price. 👎🏻

0
PJpjeffe.bsky.social

Yes, we need the Ice Ice Baby lawsuit for AI. And it has to come with big penalties. These folks have already priced in the expected penalties, so it really has to hurt.

0
Profile banner
ON
Osita Nwanevu
@ositanwanevu.bsky.social
Contributing Editor | The New Republic Columnist | The Guardian Newsletter | ositanwanevu.com
18.5k followers880 following972 posts