BLUE
RM
Randall Munroe
@xkcd.com
198.9k followers21 following342 posts
RMxkcd.com

Linguists xkcd.com/2390

24

AKandykarlson.bsky.social

Love the @ryannorth.ca guest appearance

0
XHhalftongue.bsky.social

It's a fair cop.

0
Cthecasey.bsky.social

Was this the basis for that thread, @bnb.im?

1

Hey!

0
SSottermd37.bsky.social

0
EHsiobhanftb.bsky.social

objects fall "in" holes but people fall "down" them. This distinction stems from 15th century English where reflexive verbs often followed the logic of French pronominals, where objects receive actions while people are "acted upon--" *tackled by footballer*

1
KFkarnak.bsky.social

It's a question of positionalities, surely. To "fall in" indicates a completed from-> to motion, becoming to being; you were not in the hole, now you are. Whereas "falling down" is only a singular direction of indefinite length. Could I still be falling down? So long as "down" persists, possibly...

0

distinction is: if the hole is deeper than i am tall

0
JGjhgray.bsky.social

Just now realizing "fell in a hole" seems to suggest already being in the hole when the fall commenced. Everything I know (other than experientially) about falling in holes is now in question. Falling... into a hole? Falling near a hole and THEN into it? Falling into, and then, briefly, in a hole?

1
RM
Randall Munroe
@xkcd.com
198.9k followers21 following342 posts